Reasons not to have Bariatric Surgery

Reasons not to have bariatric surgery

reasons not to have bariatric surgery
reasons not to have bariatric surgery

Reasons not to have bariatric surgery can range from as simple as a person not fulfilling the criteria or indication to have surgery to complicated medical conditions that can lead to serious post-operative issues or death of the patient.

As the saying goes:

” A good surgeon knows HOW to operate but the best surgeon knows WHEN NOT to operate”

It is important to evaluate the person who wishes to undergo surgery thoroughly so as to minimize post-surgery complications and achieve the best results.

Before a surgeon decides which procedure is the best for his patient, he must first look into any reasons not to have bariatric surgery.

Different Types of Weight Loss Surgery: Pros and Cons

Next, the surgeon must look into any reasons not to have a specific type of bariatric surgery, especially if the patient insists on or wishes to undergo it.

This happens most of the time, especially when people see their friends and relatives undergoing a specific type of surgery with unbelievable results.

The patient then insists to have the same procedure as his friend or relative which might not be suitable for him/ her.

Complications of Bariatric Surgery & How to Manage them

General Reasons not to have Bariatric Surgery:

You do not fulfil the criteria of class II or III obesity:

It is generally recommended that a person who falls into the criteria of class III obesity or class II obesity but has one or more obesity-related complications, is a candidate for bariatric surgery [Ref].

If you are overweight with a BMI of > 25 to 30 kg/m² or have class I obesity with a BMI > 30 to 35 kg/m², you are NOT a candidate for bariatric surgery.

This is one simple and basic reason not to have bariatric surgery.

BMI (Body Mass Index) Formula, Chart, Range, & Alternative Tools

Heart failure or advanced lung disease:

Both medical conditions increase the risk of intraoperative complications. As the patient may not tolerate general anaesthesia.

Either the patient may have a cardiac event during surgery or may not recover from prolonged anaesthesia.

Even if you lose weight with bariatric surgery, your medical condition may not allow you to recover or mobilize.

Going through a surgical procedure, hospitalization, and the risk of complications without expecting any improvement in the quality of life is a logical reason not to have bariatric surgery.

Diabetic Heart Failure: Causes and Treatment

However, the criteria by which a person is denied bariatric surgery are not defined and people may take risks if they think that losing weight may benefit them.

In one study, bariatric surgery in patients who had heart disease or heart failure at baseline reduced the risk of hospitalization due to heart failure, stroke, heart attack, or death by 42% [Ref]

Furthermore, morbid obesity is one contraindication of OHT (orthotopic heart transplantation). A study was conducted on patients with advanced heart failure who were candidates for OHT but because of morbid obesity, were denied a heart transplant.

Of patients who underwent bariatric surgery, 42% achieved the target BMI of <35 kg/m², and 12% underwent OHT [Ref].

Obesity and Heart Diseases: Heart Failure, A. Fibrillation, and SCD

Chronic pancreatitis and pancreatic exocrine insufficiency:

Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency refers to the insufficient release of pancreatic digestive enzymes and bicarbonate to meet the body’s demands.

Most bariatric surgeries result in pancreatic exocrine insufficiency. It is seen more commonly in surgeries involving bypasses of the GI tract.

This is because of reduced stimulation and a reduced amount of hormones entering the gut. In the case of chronic pancreatitis, the pancreas is already weekend.

Diet for Patients with Pancreatitis: Pancreatitis Diet Food List

Bariatric surgery will worsen the exocrine insufficiency of the already compromised pancreas.

Chronic pancreatitis is a reason not to have bariatric surgery as it may worsen your symptoms.

Psychiatric instability:

Post-bariatric surgery patients had attempted suicide. This was seen especially in patients who didn’t have a psychiatric evaluation before undergoing bariatric surgery.

The risk of suicide is generally < 3% of all patients undergoing bariatric surgery. In one study, patients had a 50% increased risk of death from accidents and suicide.

However, the overall mortality rate was reduced by 40% in the bariatric surgery group vs the control group [Ref].

This included:

    • 56% reduction in the rates of deaths due to cardiovascular diseases
    • 92% reduction in deaths due to diabetes, and
    • 60% reduction in deaths due to cancer.

Bariatric Surgery and Depression, Alcohol Use Disorder, & Suicidal risks

The risk of suicide is greater in patients who have:

    • a mood disorder such as major depression
    • a psychotic disorder such as schizophrenia, and
    • a personality disorder

A psychiatric evaluation is essential before a person is undergoing any kind of bariatric surgery.

No attempts to reduce weight through lifestyle intervention:

Before you choose surgery, you must try losing weight by changing your diet and start exercising.

Losing weight with a low-calorie diet and exercise leads to healthy weight loss. On the contrary, weight loss pills and surgeries are not without complications.

Lastly, even if you undergo bariatric surgery but are not compliant with a healthy diet and exercise, you may not get the desired results.

Best Weight Loss Advice for 2022: Medical Weight Loss

If you fail to lose weight with diet and exercise, bariatric surgery is the option. This will not only show motivation but also show that non-invasive techniques will unlikely result in weight loss.

Poorly Motivated patients:

Proper motivation is an essential part of bariatric surgery.  If the patient is not properly motivated and continues to consume high-calorie diets. This will once again lead to weight regain in the postoperative period.

The whole exercise and resources will go to waste. Plus, you may lose weight but the stress associated with weight loss may be difficult to handle if you are not motivated.

Which Weight Loss Surgery is the Safest?

Medical conditions as reasons for not having bariatric surgery:

Advanced medical conditions such as end-stage renal disease, liver disease, cardiopulmonary disease, stroke, and cancers that are associated with a significant reduction in life expectancy are important reasons not to have bariatric surgery.

Such patients may add more complications to their preexisting medical conditions. Furthermore, they may lose weight but may not mobilize or achieve what they desire after bariatric surgery.

Foods to Avoid with Kidney Disease and Diabetes

Affordability and Lack of Insurance:

As it is a known fact that all kinds of bariatric surgeries are costly and some insurance companies do not include these surgeries in their list.

Before undergoing bariatric surgery it is advisable to ask your insurance company. If you don’t want to proceed with insurance then on your first consultations do confirm the total approximate cost of surgery including the number of days in the hospital.

In addition, choose a surgery that you can afford. It is better to be fat and rich than slim and broke!

Complications of Bariatric Surgery & How to Manage them

Alcoholism and substance abuse:

Alcohol use disorder is a condition when a person drinks alcohol in amounts that he/ she develops social, psychological, and physical side effects. In addition, the person can not limit his/ her alcohol intake despite the fact that it is endangering his health.

A person who abuses recreational drugs or takes excessive alcohol and abuses it is not a candidate for bariatric surgery.

Bariatric Surgery and Depression, Alcohol Use Disorder, & Suicidal risks

Reasons not to have a Specific Type of Bariatric Surgery

Reasons not to opt for Intra Gastric Balloon

  • Prior gastric surgeries

Prior gastric surgery is a contraindication for intragastric balloon placement. Because scarring in the stomach wall may lead to gastric perforation.

This system act as a space-occupying lesion. Over distension in a previously significant stomach may lead to rupture leading to catastrophic complications

  • Oesophagal stricture

Intragastric balloon systems mostly are placed with help of an endoscope. So in the case of stricture in the oesophagus placing this system is difficult.

It may lead to the perforation of the oesophagus. That is  why these are not to be placed in case of oesophageal stricture

  • Pregnancy or planning to conceive in 6 months

Pregnancy is another contraindication intragastric balloon system because these are inflatable space-occupying systems. They will not allow full distension of the abdomen in late pregnancy.

  • Severe liver disease

In cases of severe liver disease, oesophagal and gastric varices are formed because of portal hypertension.

The presence of an intragastric balloon system can lead to erosion of these prices leading to massive upper gi bleeding.

  • Lesion leading to upper Gi bleeding

The presence of a previously ulcer or any other intragastric vascular malformation is a risk factor for bleeding. This is because of the risk of erosion by the presence of long-standing foreign bodies.

Gastric Sleeve Vs Balloon for Weight Loss and Diabetes

Reasons not to opt for Laparoscopic adjustable gastric banding

  • Oesophagal motility disorder

As gastric banding is associated with the development of achalasia of the oesophagus.

If the patient is already suffering from motility disorder then there is a high chance of developing oesophagal achalasia.

Which may lead to bursting of the oesophagus and developing fatal mediastinitis.

  • Patient with inflammatory bowel disease

Any patient that has inflammatory diseases or bowel is at risk of developing intragastric complications.

This happens because bands are stitched to the stomach wall which can worsen the reaction.

  • Patients with severe liver diseases

In the case of severe liver disease patients develop lower oesophageal and gastric varices. As this banding system creates a small pouch for food in the upper stomach.

This will also lead to increased pressure leading to an increased risk of bleeding from the varices.

  • Pregnancy

Whenever laparoscopy is done abdomen is insufflated with carbon dioxide. This leads to increased intra-abdominal pressure.

Because of this, the patient can have a miscarriage or other complications related to pregnancy. These kinds of complications are common, especially in late pregnancies.

  • Previous trauma or gastric surgery in the upper part of the stomach

Previous surgery or trauma to the upper part of the stomach will have scarring. This scar tissue has a weak tensile strength.

If the band is stitched in this are can lead to disruption of the anchoring suture.

  • Minors (Age younger than 18 years):

Patients of age below 18 are in the growing stage. Like other organs are under development same goes for the stomach.

When the band is applied to the upper part of the stomach. This may lead to the migration of the band from the normal site where it has to be.

  • Chronic or long-term steroid use:

Steroids use is associated with stomach ulcer formation. If the patient is already on steroids and placement of an adjustable band can lead to erosion of the stomach wall and aggravation of ulcers.

  • Pre-existing infection:

Preexisting infection can lead to contamination during surgery which may lead to the development of an intra-abdominal abscess.

  • History of autoimmune disease:

Not all autoimmune conditions are contraindications for bariatric surgery. However, autoimmune conditions that involve the gastrointestinal tract such as scleroderma and polymyositis are associated with significant oesophagal motility disorders and gastric ulcers.

Patients with these conditions should not opt for bariatric surgery. In addition, patients with other autoimmune conditions in which high doses of steroids are used are not good candidates for bariatric surgery.

Gastric Sleeve Vs Gastric Bypass Surgery: Which is Safer & Effective?

Reasons not to have Laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy

Most reasons are the same as an intragastric balloon.

Barret’s oesophagus:

This is the condition diagnosed with upper GI endoscopy. This result in chronic exposure of the oesophagal lumen to gastric acids that leads to the transformation of epithelium.

This is also a risk factor for developing malignancy. As GERD worsens after this procedure that is why this procedure shall be avoided in such cases.

Wegovy vs Sleeve Gastrectomy: Weight Loss Medicine Vs Surgery

Reasons not to have Laparoscopic Roux en y gastric bypass

Most of the reasons for not having Roux en y gastric bypass are the same same as the rest of the bariatric procedures. There are a few conditions in which this procedure shall be avoided or at least delayed if it is corrected.

  • Iron deficiency and other mineral deficiency

As in this procedure, most small gut responsible for digestion and assimilation of iron is bypassed.

Patients already having iron deficiency will lead to worsening of their medical condition.  That is why this procedure shall be avoided or corrected.

  • Vitamins deficiency

Vitamins especially Vitamin B12 are processed in part of the stock that is bypassed. this bypass will lead to the development or worsening of deficiency.

  • Medications:

Most of the medications that are used in the treatment of lifelong disorders like heart failure are absorbed in the small gut.

When this part of the gut is passed it will lead to worsening of medical conditions. That is why in such cases this kind of is to be avoided.

Gastric Sleeve Vs Gastric Bypass Surgery: Which is Safer & Effective?

Reasons not to have laparoscopic bilo pancreatic diversion and laparoscopic duodenal switch

As both procedures are almost the same except length of the common limb of the small gut. Both procedures’ operative time is extensive. It already puts patients at high risk for complications and intraoperative mortality and morbidity.

Most of the reasons are the same as Roux en y  gastric bypass

These procedures shall be avoided in patients who have a history of prior abdominal surgery, especially open surgery.

This is because of the risk of adhesion. This may complicate surgery and the risk of post-op obstruction in such patients is high.

  • Protein malnutrition

This is one of the major complications of both procedures. the patient shall be assessed for protein malnutrition. If already present this surgery shall be avoided before correction.

Protein malnutrition not only delays or impair wound healing but also affects the rest of the systems.

Pre and Post Bariatric Surgery Nutrition Guidelines and Assessment

What do you think?

Written by Dr. Ahmed

Dr. Ahmed is an experienced Internist with over fifteen years of practice in the medical field. He strongly believes that true medical practice is about helping people, not just prescribing pills.
He has found that the best results come from motivating patients to make small lifestyle changes in addition to prescribing medications when necessary.
With a focus on managing obesity, diabetes, hypertension, asthma, depression, arthritis, migraine, high cholesterol levels, and many more medical conditions in his patients, he shares his knowledge and expertise through writing health-related articles for
He is committed to helping patients achieve optimal health outcomes and improve their quality of life. For direct contact, he can be reached at

Leave a Reply

foods that boost testosterone levels for hypogonadism low testosterone symptoms

Symptoms Of Low Testosterone Level In Men and Women

quick home remedies for yeast infections symptoms of ulcerative colitis

15 Quick Home Remedies for Yeast Infections